But as his historical coming to power
unfolds, a report in the most recent publication by the Child
Care Law Reporting Project has come to the fore of national and
international discussion, throwing doubt on Ireland’s newfound claim to
political and social egalitarianism. It tells the harrowing story of a young
teenage woman who requested an abortion and believed she was going to receive
one, but found herself involuntarily committed to a psychiatric ward by her psychiatrist
under the Mental Health Act instead.
The young woman had informed her
psychiatrist that her unplanned pregnancy was making her depressed and
suicidal. The mental health practitioner did not agree that terminating the
pregnancy was the best way to treat the young woman, instead reporting her as
having a mental health disorder under Section
25 of the Mental Health Act.
The Abortion Rights Campaign was
just one of several women’s and pro-choice advocacy groups to question the
medical practitioner’s motives. Spokesperson Linda Kavanagh commented to the Irish
Mirror, “Looking at the report, it’s hard not to think that the
psychiatrist in this case essentially used the Mental Health Act as a tool to
force a child into continuing an unwanted pregnancy because of their own
personal beliefs.”
Once detained, the young woman met with
hospital and court-appointed psychiatrists, both of whom found that, while she
was depressed, she did not suffer from a psychological disorder and should not
be held. The court agreed and discharged the order, releasing the young woman
from the hospital’s custody. The report does not elaborate as to whether she
ultimately received the treatment she was seeking.
This is particularly disturbing, as it not
only highlights the draconian restrictions on abortion in Ireland – they are
only legal if the mother’s life is in immediate physical danger – but it seems
to fly in the face of a 2013
amendment which added ‘risk of loss of
life from suicide’ as the third scenario when abortions may be permitted.
This amendment followed the Ms. Y
case, where a pregnant woman went on hunger strike after being denied an
abortion, and was subsequently force-fed by court order. Ms. Y was seeking the
abortion after becoming pregnant from a rape and falling into a suicidal
depression. Ms. Kavanagh called the parallels between these two cases
“alarming.”
Not only did the Protection of Life During
Pregnancy Act supposedly enshrine a woman’s right to an abortion if her mental
health is threatened by a pregnancy, but it’s meant to protect women against
health practitioners that do not agree with abortion. Subsection 17 of the act
states: “A person who has a conscientious objection referred to in subsection
(1) shall make such arrangements for the transfer of care of the pregnant woman
concerned as may be necessary to enable the woman to avail of the medical
procedure concerned.”
Although this seems to suggest the
psychiatrist in this case acted illegally, there has been little to no
discussion of this in the surrounding conversation. Indeed, it appears Irish
women may not even be aware they have the right to a transfer of care, and
there appears to be no systems in place to ensure they know their rights and
how to act upon them. As Ms. Kavanagh stated to the Irish Mirror, “It is clear
we need some process which ensures medical professionals with such
conscientious objections cannot block timely health care in critical cases.”
So as this new era is ushered into Ireland,
it’s hard not to feel as though the new sense of equality is still only
available to a select few – namely, men. To his credit, Varadkar has promised a
referendum on abortion access. However, this comes across as merely paying lip
service to women’s bodily autonomy (pun intended), as
Irish attitudes still seem to favour only allowing abortions in cases where the
mother’s life or the life of the fetus is in danger.
For example, an October 2016 Irish
Times/Iposos MRBI poll found that only 19% of the Irish population agreed that
abortions should be provided in all cases requested. A January 2016
Newstalk/Red C poll showed slightly more promising results, with 41% of voters reporting
that abortions should be available in any circumstances a pregnant woman felt
necessary; however, this estimate still falls short of the necessary majority
to pass a legally-binding measure.
So while some communities and their allies
celebrate this new era of visibility in Ireland, it is important to remember the
fight for true equality and inclusion for all is not yet won. It is imperative
that this new visibility is wielded in the continuing battle for women’s right
to make their own reproductive and health care choices.
No comments:
Post a Comment